diff --git a/common/locales/en/content.json b/common/locales/en/content.json
index 4220c77ddc..586fea1849 100644
--- a/common/locales/en/content.json
+++ b/common/locales/en/content.json
@@ -117,6 +117,7 @@
   "hatchingPotionSpooky": "Spooky",
 
   "hatchingPotionNotes": "Pour this on an egg, and it will hatch as a <%= potText(locale) %> pet.",
+  "premiumPotionAddlNotes": "Not usable on quest pet eggs.",
 
   "foodMeat": "Meat",
   "foodMilk": "Milk",
diff --git a/common/locales/en/messages.json b/common/locales/en/messages.json
index 70c65c7b62..4b7b394656 100644
--- a/common/locales/en/messages.json
+++ b/common/locales/en/messages.json
@@ -15,7 +15,7 @@
   "messageEquipped": " <%= itemText %> equipped.",
   "messageUnEquipped": "<%= itemText %> un-equipped.",
   "messageMissingEggPotion": "You're missing either that egg or that potion",
-  "messageInvalidEggPotionCombo": "Invalid egg+potion combination. Try hatching a different egg!",
+  "messageInvalidEggPotionCombo": "You can't hatch that egg with this potion. Try a different egg!",
   "messageAlreadyPet": "You already have that pet. Try hatching a different combination!",
   "messageHatched": "Your egg hatched! Visit your stable to equip your pet.",
   "messageNotEnoughGold": "Not Enough Gold",
diff --git a/common/script/content/index.coffee b/common/script/content/index.coffee
index 1f88f38671..2fa0a0d73f 100644
--- a/common/script/content/index.coffee
+++ b/common/script/content/index.coffee
@@ -1168,7 +1168,7 @@ api.hatchingPotions =
   CottonCandyPink:  value: 4, text: t('hatchingPotionCottonCandyPink')
   CottonCandyBlue:  value: 4, text: t('hatchingPotionCottonCandyBlue')
   Golden:           value: 5, text: t('hatchingPotionGolden')
-  Spooky:           value: 3, text: t('hatchingPotionSpooky'), premium: true, limited: true
+  Spooky:           value: 3, text: t('hatchingPotionSpooky'), addlNotes: t('premiumPotionAddlNotes'), premium: true, limited: true
 
 _.each api.hatchingPotions, (pot,key) ->
   _.defaults pot, {key, value: 2, notes: t('hatchingPotionNotes', {potText: pot.text}), premium: false, limited: false, canBuy: true}
diff --git a/website/views/options/inventory/drops.jade b/website/views/options/inventory/drops.jade
index 4a98a9a57c..b64523cdfd 100644
--- a/website/views/options/inventory/drops.jade
+++ b/website/views/options/inventory/drops.jade
@@ -10,7 +10,7 @@
             p.muted(ng-show='eggCount < 1')=env.t('noEggs')
             div(ng-repeat='(egg,points) in ownedItems(user.items.eggs)')
               button.customize-option(class='Pet_Egg_{{::egg}}',
-                ng-class='{selectableInventory: selectedPotion && !(user.items.pets[egg+"-"+selectedPotion.key]>0)}',
+                ng-class='{selectableInventory: selectedPotion && !(user.items.pets[egg+"-"+selectedPotion.key]>0) && (Content.dropEggs[egg] || !selectedPotion.premium)}',
                 popover='{{::Content.eggs[egg].notes()}}', popover-append-to-body='true',
                 popover-title!=env.t("egg", {eggType: "{{::Content.eggs[egg].text()}}"}),
                 popover-trigger='mouseenter', popover-placement='right',
@@ -22,8 +22,8 @@
             p.muted(ng-show='potCount < 1')=env.t('noHatchingPotions')
             div(ng-repeat='(pot,points) in ownedItems(user.items.hatchingPotions)')
               button.customize-option(class='Pet_HatchingPotion_{{::pot}}',
-                ng-class='{selectableInventory: selectedEgg && !(user.items.pets[selectedEgg.key+"-"+pot]>0)}',
-                popover='{{::Content.hatchingPotions[pot].notes()}}',
+                ng-class='{selectableInventory: selectedEgg && !(user.items.pets[selectedEgg.key+"-"+pot]>0) && (Content.dropEggs[selectedEgg.key] || !Content.hatchingPotions[pot].premium)}',
+                popover='{{::Content.hatchingPotions[pot].notes()}} {{::Content.hatchingPotions[pot].addlNotes()}}',
                 popover-title!=env.t("potion", {potionType: "{{::Content.hatchingPotions[pot].text()}}"}),
                 popover-trigger='mouseenter', popover-placement='right',
                 popover-append-to-body='true',
@@ -148,7 +148,7 @@
           menu.pets-menu(label=env.t('magicHatchingPotions'))
             div(ng-repeat='pot in Content.hatchingPotions', ng-if='pot.premium && pot.canBuy')
               button.customize-option(class='Pet_HatchingPotion_{{::pot.key}}',
-                popover='{{::pot.notes()}}', popover-append-to-body='true',
+                popover='{{::pot.notes()}} {{::pot.addlNotes()}}', popover-append-to-body='true',
                 popover-title!=env.t("potion", {potionType: "{{::pot.text()}}"}),
                 popover-trigger='mouseenter', popover-placement='top',
                 ng-click='purchase("hatchingPotions", pot)')